JP Manus-owned horses involved in mistaken identity mix-up at Kilbeggan

JP McManus (Image: PA)

Want the day’s sports headlines straight to your inbox? Our FREE newsletter will keep you ahead of the game

Something went wrong, please try again later.Invalid EmailSign me up!We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you’ve consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. More infoThank you for subscribing!We have more newslettersShow meSee our privacy notice


A JP McManus-owned horse was caught up in a case of mistaken identity at Kilbeggan races on Friday evening.

Instead of a horse running for his first time over hurdles, it was found out that Grove Island was actually Plinth, an 11-year-old veteran over obstacles.

Grove Island, a moderate horse who had run four times on the flat without a victory, was pencilled in for a maiden hurdle at Kilbeggan.

Having run on the flat for Joseph O'Brien, the McManus-owned gelding was supposed to have switched stables two months ago to Shane Broderick.

But in an unfortunate mix up it turned out that the horse who was actually brought to Broderick's stables from McManus' Martinstown Stud was Plinth.

The latter named won a Grade 2 over hurdle back in 2015 but had not run on the track since a poor showing in a handicap hurdle last September.

The case of mistaken identity only came to light when the microchipping process prior to the race showed the real identity of the horse.

Naturally, the horse, who was actually Plinth, had to be withdrawn from the contest and an investigation into the incident will be made.

The Racing Post report that Brian Loughnane, the authorised representative from the Broderick stable, apologised for the incorrect horse showing up to the races and said they should have checked it was the correct horse when he came to their yard from Martinstown Stud.

A similar incident happened in Galway last July when a three-year-old handicapper won a two-year-old maiden. In that case both of the horses were trained by Jessica Harrington, with the microchipping process also revealing the mix-up.

Get breaking news to your inbox by signing up to our newsletter

Read More
Related Articles

  • Jockey hits back after being questioned by fan over lack of effort on gambled runner

Read More
Related Articles

  • Aidan O'Brien lands 6,407/1 accumulator after incredible English raids